>EN-LAWOFFICE>Cases>Patent Cases>How to Rebut Technical Inspirations for Patents in the Field of Traditional Building Materials? Unitalen Successfully Maintains the "Special-Shaped Pile Mold" Patent Valid in the Invalidation Case

How to Rebut Technical Inspirations for Patents in the Field of Traditional Building Materials? Unitalen Successfully Maintains the "Special-Shaped Pile Mold" Patent Valid in the Invalidation Case

Modifytime:2026-07-27

Recently, a utility model patent invalidation case represented by Unitalen saw a favorable examination outcome. The China National Intellectual Property Administration (CNIPA) issued Examination Decision No. 611477, maintaining the validity of the utility model "Special-shaped Pile Mold", based on the amendments to the claims made by the patentee.

Case Summary

This case involves the field of traditional building materials. The technical routes in this field are relatively mature, with a high density of prior art and patent literature, making inventiveness determinations prone to the pitfall of retroactively deriving technical inspiration from the results. In this case, the invalidation petitioner filed an invalidation request against all ten claims and submitted seven patent documents as evidence, attempting to deny the inventiveness of the patent involved through combinations of multiple pieces of evidence. Upon examination, the collegial panel ultimately determined that the relevant grounds for invalidation were untenable.

The focus of this case lies in whether the distinguishing feature in Claim 1, namely, "the coordinate azimuths of the corresponding inner wall base surfaces of adjacent mold shell segment units within the plane perpendicular to the mold shell centerline are not equal", has been disclosed in the prior art, or whether the prior art can provide explicit technical inspirations.

The petitioner argued that Evidence 3 (a concrete pipe pile) disclosed spiral protrusions and grooves on the outer wall of the pipe pile, and contended that the grooves could correspond to the special-shaped portions of the mold shell segment units in the patent involved, thereby obtaining the technical inspiration of "rotationally staggered distribution".

The attorney team formulated a three-tiered argument addressing the key issue in dispute.

Firstly, the product structure does not naturally equate to the mold structure. Evidence 3 concerns a concrete pipe pile as the final product and does not directly disclose the specific structure of the forming mold. The protrusions and grooves on the surface of the pipe pile are appearance features of the product, which cannot be used to directly reverse-engineer the mold shell segment units inside the mold and their azimuthal relationships.

Secondly, uncertainty about the forming method affects the chain of deduction. In the construction field, the forming methods for pipe piles are diverse. The layered spiral structure in Evidence 3 does not lead to a definite presumption that a traditional mold-forming process must be employed, let alone further speculation of the specific structure inside the mold.

Thirdly, given the different technical purposes, it is difficult to derive the same technical inspiration naturally. The purpose of providing protrusions and grooves in Evidence 3 is to "apply torsion force during pile driving, increase frictional force, and reduce material consumption". Conversely, the purpose of adjusting the azimuths in the patent involved is to "render the bearing capacity of each unit of the pile body consistent and improve structural stability". The technical problems solved and the implementation paths of Evidence 3 and the patent involved are completely different.

The collegial panel adopted the above arguments and determined that Claim 1 involves an inventive step. Consequently, based on their dependency relationships, Claims 2-9 were also maintained valid.

Case Significance

This case holds significant reference value for the right confirmation and protection of patents in traditional industries. In fields with a high density of prior art literature, the assessment of inventiveness must not be confined to a mere listing of features or a superficial comparison of similarities. The disclosure, technical purposes, and application scenarios of the prior art, as well as whether those skilled in the art can hold a clear motivation for improvement, shall all undergo concrete analysis in light of the facts of the case.

Views:Back