>EN-LAWOFFICE>Cases>Trademark Cases>"TATA Doors" Represented by Unitalen Achieves First Administrative Recognition of Well-Known Trademark, Successfully Invalidating Multiple TATA Copycat Trademarks

"TATA Doors" Represented by Unitalen Achieves First Administrative Recognition of Well-Known Trademark, Successfully Invalidating Multiple TATA Copycat Trademarks

Modifytime:2026-08-17

Case Brief

Since 2003, Zhejiang TATA Doors Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as "TATA" or "Principal") has been using its trademark  on goods such as "non-metal doors". With continuous business operations, promotion, and use, the trademark has become widely known to the relevant public. Since 2017, the third party, Suzhou Boshilong Smart Home Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as "Boshilong"), has filed batch applications to register over 70 marks similar to the Principal's "TATA" trademarks across multiple classes of goods, including "TATAZNJJ" and "TATAZNS". Unitalen represented the Principal in filing invalidity requests against multiple of these trademarks with the China National Intellectual Property Administration (CNIPA).

During the administrative stage, TATA submitted a substantial amount of evidence, including sales contracts, audit reports, advertising contracts and invoices, search reports from the National Library, recommendation letters from industry associations, and prior civil judgments, in order to prove that the "TATA Doors" trademark had achieved well-known status and that the disputed trademarks of the third party constituted reproduction and imitation of the well-known trademark. However, the CNIPA rendered the contested ruling, finding only that the disputed trademarks were similar to the cited trademark on certain goods and invalidating them accordingly. It did not support TATA's claim for well-known trademark protection, thereby maintaining the registration of the disputed trademarks on the majority of the goods.

TATA then filed an administrative lawsuit with the Beijing Intellectual Property Court. After trial, the court of first instance comprehensively overturned the conclusions set out in the contested ruling regarding recognition of the well-known trademark. For the first time in administrative litigation, the court recognized that the Principal's "TATA Doors" trademark had constituted a well-known trademark on "non-metal doors". In accordance with Article 13, Paragraph 3 of the Trademark Law of the People's Republic of China, the court ruled to revoke the contested ruling and ordered the CNIPA to render a new ruling.

Both CNIPA and Boshilong disagreed with the first-instance judgment and filed appeals with the Beijing High People's Court, arguing that the recognition of the well-known trademark in the first-instance judgment was erroneous. After conducting an open trial, the Beijing High People's Court rendered a second-instance judgment as the final judgment, dismissing the appeal and affirming the original judgment.

Case Significance

The present case marks the first time the trademark " " has been recognized as a well-known trademark in an administrative trademark litigation. The recognition of the well-known trademark in this administrative litigation sets a precedent for subsequent administrative cases concerning trademark authorization and confirmation and provides a solid foundation for rights protection measures. In addition, the present case is one of a batch-invalidation cases filed by TATA against the TATA copycat trademarks registered under the name of Boshilong. The invalidation of these trademarks has effectively purified the market environment and safeguarded the brand goodwill cast by TATA over the years.

Views:Back